Indy Card Exchange is an Official PSA Authorized Dealer. What that means is you can submit cards to us for grading, we then send your cards along with other customers in a group order to PSA, and they then can be picked up back at our shop when they are completed and shipped back to us from PSA. Customers choose to submit through us as it saves money on shipping and insurance versus sending them in yourself.
We only accept in-store submissions and cannot take mail-in submissions at this time due to demand.
If you are interested in submitting cards through the shop, please create an account through our “grading portal” for the necessary information on available service levels, estimated turnaround times, cost per card, and what we ask of you the customer to agree to.
Orders are sent once per month but you can drop off cards at anytime. The modern bulk level usually goes out every week. Please check out the events calendar to see when our next submission is being sent out. You will be contacted through email once your order has been completed by PSA and has arrived back at the shop.
For more information on PSA the company, please visit their website HERE.
PSA Grading Stage Spreadsheet (Check the status of your PSA Grading Order using your provided submission #. Last updated on 11/19/24)
*The spreadsheet is only for orders that were submitted using our paper forms before we moved to this online site. If you submitted through the site, the information is in your grading portal dashboard.*
| Grading Stages | Detailed Info On The Different Stages |
| Arrived At Shop | Cards have been confirmed delivered to shop, but not sent to grading company yet |
| Research & ID | Cards have now arrived at PSA and been entered into their system |
| Grading | Cards are in the grading stage. The time it takes to grade could range from weeks to months |
| Assembly | Cards have been graded and are being placed into holders |
| QA Check 1 | Quality Assurance Check 1 – First round of reviews |
| QA Check 2 | Quality Assurance Check 2 – Second round of reviews |
| Completed | Done & Back At The Shop |
Grading Submission Card Review
Indy Card Exchange offers grading consultations and card prep for a fee of $3 per card (max 50 cards) and are done by appointment only. This review may include determining what cards are worth being sent in for grading based of value and condition, what grading service you will want to use, and of course reviewing the condition of each card you want to potentially submit. If you are interested in having your cards reviewed, please email us or send us a message through the “Contact Us” tab at the top right of the website to schedule a grading consultation. Please include about how many cards you plan on having us review so we know how much time we will need for the appointment. We will do our best to respond as soon as we can, but it may take 24-48 business hours during busy times. You do not have to have your cards reviewed by us to submit through us. This is just an optional service available to you.